,

Why Is It Snowing When It’s Above Freezing?

Snow above freezing

Quick answer

Snow doesn’t need the temperature at ground level to be below 0°C. The Met Office says “precipitation falls as snow when the air temperature is below 2 °C”, and that “the heaviest snowfalls tend to occur when the air temperature is between zero and 2 °C.” Snow forms high in the clouds where it’s well below freezing. As it falls into slightly milder air, it starts to melt, and the melting and evaporating cool the air around it. That cooling can be enough to keep the flakes frozen all the way to the ground.

The plain-English version

It feels like it shouldn’t be possible. The car dashboard says 2°C, the puddles aren’t frozen, and yet big wet snowflakes are drifting past the window.

The trick is that snow is made a long way above your head, where it’s much colder than at street level. A snowflake falling from a cloud is like an ice cube dropped from a freezer into a cool room. It doesn’t turn into water the moment it leaves the freezer. It takes time to melt, and while it’s melting it soaks up heat from the air around it, cooling that air down.

On top of that, as some of the snow melts and some evaporates, the air it’s falling through gets chillier still. Steady snowfall can, in effect, refrigerate the air it’s falling through. If the air near the ground is only a little above freezing, the snow can survive the trip.

The deeper science

Where snow is born

The Met Office explains that “snow forms when tiny ice crystals in clouds stick together to become snowflakes.” Up in the cloud, temperatures are well below 0°C, so almost all precipitation in our winter clouds starts life frozen. The Met Office notes that “most precipitation in the clouds starts off as snow or supercooled raindrops.”

The question isn’t whether snow forms, but whether it survives the journey down. That depends on the layer of air between the cloud and the ground.

The freezing level

Meteorologists talk about the freezing level, which the Met Office describes as “the altitude at which temperatures drop below zero.” Above it, the air is below 0°C. Below it, the air is above 0°C. If the freezing level is high above the ground, snow falling from the cloud has a long way to fall through above-freezing air, and it usually melts into rain. If the freezing level is close to the ground, the snow has only a short warm stretch to cross, and much of it can arrive still frozen.

This is also why hills often get snow while the valleys below get rain. The tops of the hills are closer to, or above, the freezing level.

Melting cools the air

Here’s the key bit. Turning ice into water takes heat, and that heat has to come from somewhere. As a snowflake begins to melt, it takes heat from the air around it. The Met Office puts it like this: “the falling snow does begin to melt as soon as the temperature rises above freezing, but as the melting process begins, the air around the snowflake is cooled.”

When a lot of snow is falling, all that melting cools the whole layer of air. The Met Office notes that “heavy bursts of precipitation can cool the air near the surface, increasing the chance of snow. Conversely, lighter precipitation may melt before reaching the ground.” That’s why a shower that starts as rain can turn to snow when it gets heavier, and back to rain when it eases.

Evaporation cools it even more

There’s a second cooling effect. Some of the water from melting flakes evaporates into the air, and evaporation takes even more heat than melting does. It’s the same reason you shiver getting out of a swimming pool on a breezy day.

Meteorologists measure this with the wet-bulb temperature, which the Met Office defines as “the lowest temperature that can be achieved through evaporative cooling.” In dry air, a lot of evaporation can happen, so the air can cool a long way below the ordinary thermometer reading. In very moist air, there’s less room for evaporation. The Met Office explains that if the air is fully saturated, “evaporation stops”, and the wet-bulb temperature equals the normal temperature.

So snow at 2°C is more likely when the air is fairly dry. As the precipitation falls into it, evaporation pulls the temperature down towards freezing.

Read more: Why Do Weather Forecasts Get It Wrong? (And What “30% Chance of Rain” Means)

Why “wet snow” happens

When it’s just above freezing, the snowflakes don’t stay perfect little crystals. The Met Office says that when the temperature is slightly warmer than 0°C, “the snowflakes will melt around the edges and stick together to become big, heavy flakes. This creates ‘wet’ snow which sticks together easily.” These are the big, fat flakes that are perfect for snowmen, and they’re also heavy on branches, power lines and greenhouse roofs.

Read more: Can Snow Damage Your Conservatory, Greenhouse or Carport?

Snow, sleet or rain?

Between snow and rain there’s sleet, which the Met Office describes in the UK as “a combination or mix of rain and snow”. It’s frozen precipitation that has partly melted on the way down. In practice, as temperatures hover around the 1 to 3°C mark, you can see rain, sleet and snow in the same day, or even the same hour.

There’s another, rarer type too. Freezing rain happens when snow melts into rain in a warm layer high up, then falls into freezing air just above the ground. The Met Office explains that the drops become “supercooled”, still liquid even though they’re below zero, and when they hit freezing surfaces they “instantly freeze, encasing the surface in a layer of clear ice.” It adds that “we don’t see this phenomenon very often in the UK.”

Read more: Sleet, Hail, Graupel or Freezing Rain: What’s the Difference?

Snow above freezing

A real-world example: snow in a “mild” Britain

Britain’s snow is often a borderline affair. The Met Office says the UK gets an average of 13 days of lying snow a year (1991–2020), and Scotland around 23 days. Because so much of our snow falls close to the 0 to 2°C range, a shift of just a degree or two, or a change in how heavily it’s falling, can decide whether a town gets a covering or a soaking.

The Met Office describes snow forecasting as “one of the most uncertain aspects of UK weather prediction”, noting that “small variations in temperature or wind direction can mean the difference between rain, sleet or snow.”

Read more: Are White Christmases Really Rarer Than They Used to Be?

Common misconceptions

“It has to be below freezing to snow.” The Met Office calls this “a myth”. Snow can fall when the air near the ground is up to about 2°C.

“If it’s snowing, it’ll settle.” Not necessarily. At 1 or 2°C, snow often melts as it lands, especially on warm roads and pavements. It settles more readily on grass, cars and rooftops, or once heavy snowfall has cooled the ground.

“The heaviest snow comes in the coldest weather.” In Britain, the heaviest falls tend to come when it’s between 0 and 2°C. Very cold air often holds less moisture, which we’ll look at in our “too cold to snow” article.

Read more: Is It Ever “Too Cold to Snow”?

“Rain turning to snow means the temperature has suddenly dropped a lot.” Often it’s only a small change. A heavier burst of precipitation can cool the air just enough to tip rain into snow.

FAQ

Why does rain turn to snow when it gets heavier?

Heavier precipitation means more melting and evaporation, which cool the air near the ground. The Met Office says heavy bursts “can cool the air near the surface, increasing the chance of snow.”

Why do the hills have snow when it’s raining in town?

Because temperatures usually fall as you go higher. The hills are closer to, or above, the freezing level, so the snow has less above-freezing air to melt in.

Does humidity matter?

Yes. In drier air, more evaporation can take place, cooling the air further and helping snow survive. In saturated air, evaporation stops.

Why are wet snowflakes so big?

At just above freezing, flakes partly melt at the edges and stick together into large, heavy clumps.

Sources