It’s one of the great British household arguments. One person insists it’s cheaper to leave the heating ticking over all day. Another says that’s money down the drain. So who’s right? The answer depends on what kind of heating you have, and there are a few important exceptions.
Quick answer
For most homes with a gas, oil or LPG boiler, it’s usually cheaper to heat your home only when you need it, using a timer and a thermostat, than to leave the heating on low all day. The Energy Saving Trust is cited as saying that “leaving your heating on all day uses more energy than turning it on only when you need it.” But there are exceptions. Heat pumps generally work best left running steadily with a small setback rather than switched off. And when you’re away in a cold snap, leave the heating on low to protect your pipes.
The short version, by heating type
| Your heating | Best approach | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Gas, oil or LPG boiler | Use a timer to heat the home when you’re in, and a room thermostat to stop it overheating | Heating an empty home all day uses more energy overall |
| Heat pump | Keep it on for longer periods, with a slightly lower “setback” temperature when you’re out or asleep, rather than switching it off | Heat pumps work more efficiently at steady, lower temperatures, and reheating a cold home makes them work much harder |
| Any system, while you’re away in winter | Leave the heating on low | To help stop pipes freezing |
| Any system, if someone at home is older or unwell | Keep at least one room warm while they’re home | Cold homes can harm health |
Based on advice from the Energy Saving Trust, a UK government factsheet, Nesta and the Met Office.
Why it matters: what the evidence says
Why “on low all day” usually costs more with a boiler
Your home is always leaking heat to the outside, through the walls, roof, windows and draughts. The warmer the inside is compared with the outside, the faster the heat leaks away.
Think of your house as a bucket with a hole in it, and the heating as a tap filling it. The fuller the bucket (the warmer the house), the faster water pours out of the hole. Keep the bucket topped up all day, and water is pouring out all day, even when nobody’s home. Let the level drop while you’re out, and less escapes. Yes, you need a burst from the tap to fill it up again, but in total you usually use less water.
A UK government factsheet tackled this head-on. Asked whether it’s better to leave the heating on low constantly, it answered: “No, this will mean your home will be heated when you are not there and it may be too cold when you are there. It is better to use a programmer/timer to ensure the heating is on when you are home and off when you are not.” It says installing and correctly using a full set of heating controls “could save you around £80 to £165 a year” for a typical household.
Small changes, real savings
The Energy Saving Trust says that turning your thermostat down by one degree, “from 22°C to 21°C, you could save £120 in GB and £80 in NI.” It also points out that you “don’t need to turn your thermostat up when it is colder outside”: the thermostat will keep the boiler running for longer to reach the same temperature.
Read more: How Warm Should Your Home Be in Winter?
Why heat pumps are different
Heat pumps are the big exception. The Energy Saving Trust advises: “keep your heat pump on for extended periods” rather than turning it on and off through the day. It explains that “if the temperature of your home drops by a few degrees, your heat pump has to work a lot harder to warm it again.”
Nesta, the innovation charity, agrees that “turning a heat pump off at night can be inefficient, as it forces the system to work harder to recover the lost heat.” Instead, it suggests “using a setback temperature – a slightly lower setting during off peak hours”, which it says “can save energy without reducing comfort.”
The Energy Saving Trust adds that lowering a heat pump’s flow temperature (how hot it heats the water in the radiators) has a big effect on running costs, and recommends lowering the heat pump’s flow temperature gradually until the house stops feeling comfortable, then turning it back up a degree.
Where the “leave it on” idea comes from
The belief isn’t silly. It feels as though a cold house takes a huge amount of energy to warm up again. And for some homes and situations, a steadier approach really is sensible:
- Heat pumps, as above.
- Homes with damp or condensation problems. Government guidance on damp and mould says homes that are adequately heated are “less prone to developing damp and mould, provided that ventilation is adequate.” Letting a home get very cold can make condensation worse.
- When someone vulnerable is at home all day. In that case the home isn’t empty, so heating it isn’t wasted.
- Frost protection. When you’re away in winter, the Met Office advises: “If you are going away, leave your heating on low.” That’s about protecting pipes, not saving money.
Read more: How to Stop Condensation and Mould in Winter · At What Temperature Do Pipes Freeze?
The honest answer is that the “on low all day” debate depends on your system, your home and who’s in it. For a typical boiler-heated home that’s empty during the day, the evidence points towards heating it when you need it.

Before, during and after the cold months
Before winter
- Find out what controls you have. A timer or programmer, a room thermostat and thermostatic radiator valves (TRVs) on individual radiators. The Energy Saving Trust explains that TRVs “help you control the temperature in individual rooms.”
- Set your timer so the heating comes on shortly before you get up and before you get home.
- Set the room thermostat to the lowest comfortable temperature. The government factsheet suggests a room thermostat setting between 18°C and 21°C.
- If you have a heat pump, check its schedule uses setbacks rather than switching off, and ask your installer about the flow temperature.
Through the winter
- Don’t turn the thermostat up when it’s colder outside. It won’t heat the house faster.
- Turn TRVs down in rooms you don’t use, but don’t let any room get so cold that damp becomes a problem.
- Going away? Leave the heating on low, or use your boiler’s frost protection setting if it has one.
After a cold snap
- Check for signs of condensation or mould in rooms you kept cool.
- Review your bills. If they’ve jumped, see whether your timer and thermostat settings match your routine.
Common mistakes
- Turning the thermostat right up to warm the house faster. It doesn’t work that way. It just overshoots.
- Switching a heat pump on and off like a boiler. That can make it less efficient.
- Leaving the heating on all day in an empty house, with a boiler, “to save money”.
- Switching the heating off completely when you go away in winter. That risks frozen pipes.
- Keeping the house so cool that it gets damp. Saving a little on heating can cost more in mould damage and health.
When to call a professional
- Your boiler won’t keep the house warm, cycles on and off constantly or shows fault codes: call a Gas Safe registered engineer (or an OFTEC-registered technician for oil).
- Your heat pump bills seem too high: ask your installer to check the settings, including the flow temperature and schedule.
- You’d like better controls, such as a programmer, room thermostat or TRVs: a heating engineer can fit them.
- You’re struggling to afford heating: contact your energy supplier or local council about support.
Printable: Heating plan printable (PDF)
Sources
- Energy Saving Trust: Thermostats and heating controls: https://energysavingtrust.org.uk/advice/thermostats-and-heating-controls/
- Energy Saving Trust: The most efficient way to run a heat pump: https://energysavingtrust.org.uk/how-to-ensure-a-heat-pump-runs-efficiently/
- Places for People: Busting home energy saving myths (citing the Energy Saving Trust): https://www.placesforpeople.co.uk/helpful-guides-tips/my-place-blog/busting-home-energy-saving-myths/
- UK Government (DECC) factsheet: Keeping cosy and warm for less (2016): https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/587336/DECC_factsheet_11.11.16_KEEPING_COZY_AND_WARM_FOR_LESS_LOCKED.pdf
- Nesta: Does turning off the heat pump affect heating? https://www.nesta.org.uk/report/what-homeowners-want-to-know-about-heat-pumps-data-driven-faqs/does-turning-off-the-heat-pump-affect-heating/
- Met Office: What to do if you have a frozen or burst pipe: https://weather.metoffice.gov.uk/warnings-and-advice/seasonal-advice/your-home/frozen-or-burst-pipes
- GOV.UK: Understanding and addressing the health risks of damp and mould in the home: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/damp-and-mould-understanding-and-addressing-the-health-risks-for-rented-housing-providers/understanding-and-addressing-the-health-risks-of-damp-and-mould-in-the-home–2
