,

“Mackerel Sky and Mares’ Tails Make Tall Ships Take In Their Sails”

Mackerel sky

Look up on an autumn afternoon and you may see the sky covered in tiny rippled cloudlets, like fish scales, or high wispy streaks that look like a horse’s tail blowing in the wind. Old sailors read these as a warning. Were they right?

VERDICT: PARTIALLY TRUE

High, wispy cirrus often forms ahead of a warm front, so it can be an early sign of a change to wetter, windier weather. But a mackerel sky on its own is a much less reliable sign, and neither cloud guarantees a storm.

Where the saying came from

The saying comes from the days of sail, when ship crews had no forecasts and read the sky to judge when to shorten sail before a blow. The Met Office quotes one version as “Mackerel sky and mare’s tails make tall ships carry low sails”. Others end with “take in their sails” or “lower their sails”. The meaning is the same: when you see these clouds, get ready for wind and rain.

The two clouds in the saying are:

  • Mares’ tails: high, wispy streaks of cloud, curled at the ends like a horse’s tail. Meteorologists call these cirrus.
  • Mackerel sky: a sky dappled with small, regular cloudlets in rows, like the scales on a mackerel’s skin.

What the science says

Mares’ tails: an early warning

The Met Office describes cirrus as “short, detached, hair-like clouds”, “made up completely of ice crystals”, found between 20,000 and 40,000 feet. Crucially, it says they “often form in advance of a warm front”, signalling that “a change in the weather is on the way.”

Here’s why. At a warm front, a mass of warmer air rides up over the colder air ahead of it. The Met Office’s factsheet describes this as “warm air is advancing and rising up over cold air”. The boundary slopes very gently, which the Met Office puts at about 1 in 150 on average, so the first signs of the front appear high in the sky long before it arrives at ground level. The same factsheet describes “increasing amounts of upper cloud, thickening and lowering with approach of front”, with rain starting roughly “200 – 400 km ahead” of where the front meets the ground.

Picture a long, gently sloping ramp. The far end, high up, is over your head first. The bottom of the ramp, where the rain is, arrives later. The Met Office says warm fronts advance at around 20 to 30 mph, so the gap between the first wisps of cirrus and the rain can be several hours or more.

The cloud sequence usually goes:

1. Cirrus (mares’ tails), the high, wispy first sign.

2. Cirrostratus, a thin, milky veil across the sky. The Met Office says that if a type called cirrostratus nebulosus appears, “it is likely that an incoming warm front will bring persistent rain within a day.”

3. Altostratus, a thicker, grey sheet. The Met Office says these clouds “often form ahead of a warm or occluded front”, deepening into nimbostratus, which brings rain or snow.

4. Low, thick rain cloud as the front arrives.

Read more: Why Does Britain Have Such Changeable Weather?

Mackerel sky: a mixed signal

The mackerel sky is where things get muddled, and the Met Office’s own pages show why.

Its page on high clouds says that cirrocumulus, high cloudlets “made up of both ice and ‘supercooled’ water”, “can sometimes appear to look like the scaly skin of a fish and is referred to as a mackerel sky.” It adds that cirrocumulus is “usually associated with fair weather. However, their appearance can often prelude stormy weather.”

Its weather-lore page instead links the mackerel sky to altocumulus, lower cloudlets which, it says, “appear when there is a certain level of moisture in the air suggesting rainfall is approaching”. Yet its page on mid-level clouds says altocumulus is “mostly found in settled weather”, and that rain from it rarely reaches the ground.

In other words, fish-scale skies come in more than one form, and they can appear in both fair and unsettled weather. What matters is the bigger picture: is the cloud thickening and lowering from the west, and is cirrus spreading in too?

The clouds at a glance

CloudHeight of baseLooks likeWhat the Met Office says it can signal
Cirrus (“mares’ tails”)20,000–40,000 ftWispy, hair-like streaks of ice crystalsOften forms ahead of a warm front
Cirrocumulus (“mackerel sky”)20,000–40,000 ftRows of tiny, fish-scale cloudletsUsually fair weather, but can come before stormy weather
Cirrostratus20,000–40,000 ftA thin, milky veil of iceThe nebulosus type suggests persistent rain within a day
Altocumulus7,000–18,000 ftRounded clumps or rolls of cloudMostly found in settled weather
Altostratus6,500–20,000 ftA grey sheet with the sun showing weaklyOften forms ahead of a warm or occluded front

What comes after the rain

The warm front isn’t the end of the story. The Met Office factsheet explains that a cold front usually follows, bringing “a fairly narrow band of rain”. Cold fronts can move faster than warm ones, at around 40 to 50 mph compared with 20 to 30 mph. When a cold front catches up with a warm front, the two merge into an occluded front, and the warm air is “forced up from the surface”.

So the full sequence for a classic Atlantic low might be: mares’ tails, a veiled sky and steady rain from the warm front, a milder and often murkier spell, then a sharper burst of rain as the cold front passes, followed by brighter, cooler, showery weather. Sailors who saw mares’ tails were seeing the first act of a play that could last a day or more.

The grain of truth

The saying works best when both clouds appear together and the sky is getting steadily cloudier. That pattern, high cirrus spreading in and then a dappled or veiled sky thickening and lowering, matches the classic approach of a warm front described by the Met Office. For sailors in the open sea, that was genuinely useful hours of warning.

Where it falls down:

  • Cirrus doesn’t always mean a front. The Met Office says it “often” forms ahead of one, not always.
  • A mackerel sky alone is ambiguous. As the Met Office’s own descriptions show, it can be associated with fair weather as well as an approaching change.
  • It says nothing about how bad the weather will be. A warm front might bring a few hours of drizzle, or the leading edge of a named storm.
  • It doesn’t tell you when. The rain could be hours away, or a day.

The saying is a decent prompt to check the forecast, not a forecast in itself.

Read more: “Red Sky at Night, Shepherd’s Delight”: Is It True? · Do Lots of Berries Mean a Hard Winter?

How to read the sky yourself

  • Look west. In the UK, most of our weather arrives from the west, so that’s where an approaching front will show first.
  • Watch for a trend. One patch of cirrus means little. Cirrus spreading in, followed by a thin veil and then thicker grey cloud over a few hours, is the classic warm-front sequence.
  • Then check the forecast. If a warning is out, the clouds are just the trailer for the main feature.

Read more: Does a Ring Around the Moon Mean Rain Is Coming? · What Do Met Office Weather Warning Colours Actually Mean?

Sources