Do Rubber Tyres Protect You From Lightning in a Car?

Rubber tyres

It’s one of the best-known bits of lightning “wisdom”: you’re safe in a car during a thunderstorm because the rubber tyres insulate you from the ground. The first half is broadly true. The second half isn’t. It’s not the tyres that protect you. It’s the metal around you.

VERDICT: FALSE (BUT THE CAR DOES PROTECT YOU)

Rubber tyres don’t protect you from lightning. NOAA says “rubber soles of shoes (or rubber tires) are not insulators from lightning.” What protects you in a car is its metal roof and sides. The US National Weather Service (NWS) says “the outer metal shell of hard-topped metal vehicles does provide protection to those inside” a closed vehicle. The lightning passes through the metal shell, then through the tyres to the ground. That’s why NOAA says an “enclosed, metal-topped vehicle with windows up” is a safe shelter, but “convertible vehicles offer no safety from lightning”, and why a motorbike or bicycle won’t protect you either.

Where it came from

It’s easy to see why the myth caught on. Most of us learn that rubber is an electrical insulator: it’s what covers the wires in our homes. Cars sit on four rubber tyres, so it seems to follow that the tyres must stop the electricity reaching the ground.

And the basic advice is right: a hard-topped car is a safe place to shelter. It’s just the explanation that’s wrong.

What the science says

Why the tyres make no difference

Rubber is a good insulator for the electricity in your home. Against lightning, it’s no match. Physicist Christopher Baird of West Texas A&M University explains that rubber insulates only “at low voltages”, and that lightning’s voltage is “far too high to be stopped by tires or air.”

Think about it this way: a lightning bolt has just forced its way from the cloud to the ground through the air, which is itself an insulator. A few centimetres of rubber isn’t going to stop it.

What really protects you: the metal shell

A hollow metal box protects whatever is inside it from electricity outside. This is called a Faraday cage, after the scientist Michael Faraday. Christopher Baird says a fully enclosed metal vehicle protects you through this effect.

Live Science puts it simply: “The lightning charge goes around the outside of the vehicle, creating a Faraday effect and protecting the occupants inside.”

Think of the car’s metal body as a motorway bypass around a town. The lightning’s current takes the bypass, flowing around the outside of the car through the metal, rather than going through the middle, where you’re sitting.

The NWS describes the path: lightning usually strikes the aerial or roofline, then “will then pass through the vehicle’s outer metal shell, then through the tires to the ground.”

It can still damage the car

You’ll probably be fine, but your car might not be. The NWS says common damage includes the aerial, the electrical system, the rear windscreen and the tyres. It says “it’s very common for the lightning to destroy one or more tires as it passes through the steel belts to the ground,” and a strike can occasionally start a fire.

Which vehicles don’t protect you

The protection depends on being fully enclosed by metal. So:

  • Convertibles: NOAA says they “offer no safety from lightning”, even with the roof up.
  • Motorbikes and bicycles: Christopher Baird says riding one during a lightning storm “is a bad idea”. The UCAR Center for Science Education says convertibles, motorcycles, bicycles “and vehicles without a metal roof offer no protection from lightning.”
  • Open vehicles: NOAA says vehicles with “open cabs, such as golf carts, tractors, and construction equipment” are unsafe.
  • Fibreglass vehicles, or any car with the windows open: Richard Kithil of the US National Lightning Safety Institute, quoted by Live Science, says these “help defeat the fully enclosed objective.”

What to do if you’re in a car during a storm

  • Close the windows. NOAA says the windows should be up.
  • Avoid touching metal parts that lead to the outside. NOAA says to “avoid contact with any conducting paths leading to the outside of the vehicle”, such as radios and the ignition. Live Science reports the National Lightning Safety Institute’s advice to pull over safely, turn the engine off, keep your hands in your lap and avoid touching door and window controls, the steering wheel and the gear stick.
  • Don’t lean on the outside of the car. The NWS asks: “Do the rubber tires on your car protect you if you are OUTside the car and you’re leaning on it? NO!”

Read more: Lightning Safety Outdoors: What to Do If You’re Caught Out

Where lightning goes in a car

The grain of truth

The bit that’s true is the bit that matters most: a hard-topped metal car is a safe place to be in a thunderstorm. If you’re caught out in the open, NOAA lists an enclosed, metal-topped vehicle with the windows up as a safe shelter when there’s no substantial building nearby. So the advice to get into the car is good advice. It’s only the reason that’s wrong, and that matters, because people who believe it’s the tyres might think a convertible, a tractor or a quad bike would protect them too.

Read more: How Does Thunder Work, and How Far Away Is the Storm? · Can Lightning Strike Out of a Clear Blue Sky?

Sources